Bayley Fires Back at Nikki Bella’s “Original Four Horsewomen” Instagram Caption After WrestleMania 42

Nikki Bella managed to spark a social media debate within hours of one of the most emotional nights of her career. After the Women’s Tag Team Championship match at WrestleMania 42, Nikki posted a backstage photo with Brie Bella and Paige with a caption that immediately drew attention — and a very direct response from Bayley.

“The Original Four Horsewomen,” Nikki wrote alongside the image of the three women celebrating the title win. Bayley — who is part of the widely recognized WWE Four Horsewomen alongside Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch, and Sasha Banks — saw the caption and was not about to let it slide. “NEVER IN MY LIFE HAVE I EVER HEARD ANYONE CALL YOU GUYS THAT,” Bayley wrote in the comments.

The exchange immediately caught fire online, with fans debating whether Nikki intended the caption seriously or was simply having fun with the label in the emotion of the moment. The timing made the situation more charged given the dramatic circumstances of the night — Nikki had arrived at ringside on crutches, announced she was unable to compete due to her fractured ankle, introduced Paige as her replacement, and then watched Paige win the championships in her first WWE match since 2017.

Bayley and Lyra Valkyria Lost the Women’s Tag Title Match as Paige Countered Twisted Bliss to Win the Championships

Paige’s actual in-ring performance gave Nikki and Brie plenty of legitimate reasons to celebrate — she traded shots with Nia Jax, got involved with Bayley and Lash Legend, and delivered the decisive moment by countering Alexa Bliss’s Twisted Bliss into a Rampaige for the winning pinfall. The caption controversy does not diminish what was unquestionably one of WrestleMania 42’s most memorable moments — but Bayley made it very clear she will not be allowing any historical revisionism to go unchallenged on her watch.