Becky Lynch Explains Why Her First On-Screen Run With Seth Rollins Failed In 2019

It is hard to imagine a time when the pairing of Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch wasn’t a surefire hit, but in 2019, the reality was quite different. Following WrestleMania 35, both superstars were atop the WWE mountain—Lynch as the double champion after defeating Charlotte Flair and Ronda Rousey, and Rollins as the Universal Champion after conquering Brock Lesnar. WWE creative made the decision to pair the real-life couple on-screen immediately, but the storyline was met with significant backlash from fans who felt it was forced and unnatural.

Becky Lynch Explains Struggles Of 2019 WWE Run With Seth Rollins

In a candid new interview with Billboard, Lynch opened up about why that first run struggled to connect with the audience. She revealed that the timing was simply wrong, as the two had barely begun their relationship when they were thrust into the spotlight together. “The last time we didn’t know each other in our relationship setting. We just started dating. We were together like two months at that point,” Lynch explained. She noted that trying to figure out their character dynamic on global television before they had even established their real-life dynamic created a recipe for disaster.

Lynch described the experience as “tense, hard and difficult,” exacerbated by a commentary team that was instructed to mention their relationship constantly. “If that wasn’t bad enough, you had the announcers every two seconds saying that we were in a real life relationship and people were just nauseated by it… We felt like we were doing something wrong,” she admitted. The overexposure led to a disconnect that took years to repair in the eyes of the viewing public.

How “Big Time Becks” And Seth Rollins Found Chemistry In 2025

Fast forward to the present day, and the dynamic has completely shifted. Lynch told Billboard that being married for nearly five years and raising a daughter together has created a comfort level that translates perfectly to the screen. “We’re very comfortable where we’re settled into our relationship and dynamic,” she said. She joked that their larger-than-life personas—”Big Time Becks” and “Seth Freakin Rollins”—are “a bit much” individually, but “together, it works out perfectly.”

This evolved chemistry was on full display last year when the couple reunited on-screen to feud with CM Punk and AJ Lee, culminating in a high-profile mixed tag team match at WrestlePalooza. Unlike the forced interactions of 2019, this run was praised for its authenticity and intensity, proving that sometimes even the best ideas just need the right timing to succeed.

Make sure to follow us on social media by liking us on Facebook at WrestleStarz and subscribing to us on YouTube at WrestleStar YouTube.